Real Estate News

Apartment REITs See High Renewals but Sluggish New Lease Rates

Renewal rents rose 5.3% at three of the five landlords RealPage tracked, while new-lease rates declined at four.

Story Photo
It's a tale of two different stories for apartment REITs. On one hand, renewals are high, with tenants choosing to stay due to elevated homeownership costs — yet new leasing has been sluggish.

REITs Essex Property Trust, Mid-America Apartment Communities and Vivmark Residential each reported a 5.3 percent rise in renewal rates, with Camden Property Trust's coming in at 3.6 percent, according to a RealPage analysis. Additionally, UDR reported a third-quarter retention record of 52%.

Mid-America Apartment Communities or MAA, illustrated how far the two sides of the leasing business had diverged. Its renewal rents rose 5.3% even as new-lease rates fell 6%, the largest decline among the five REITs. Vivmark was the only landlord in the group to post an increase on new leases, at 0.4%.

Executives pointed to high homeownership costs as one reason residents were staying longer. MAA said home purchases accounted for a record-low 10.1% of its move-outs. The company also said the gap between new and renewal rents had held at about $190 to $200 for four quarters, a difference it viewed as small relative to the cost and hassle of moving.

Camden and MAA attributed much of the weakness in new-lease pricing to discounts at properties still filling units and to the mix of leases being signed.

MAA said its year-to-date decline in new-lease rates narrowed to 1.9% when it looked only at units where the outgoing tenant had stayed for a single lease term. The company viewed that narrower measure as a better gauge of current market rents.

Financial Results Vary By Region

Results also varied sharply by market. In Northern California, same-store net operating income rose 11.2% at Vivmark and 7% at Essex. In Denver, it fell 9.6% at Vivmark and nearly 7% at both Camden and MAA. Camden attributed most of its Denver revenue decline to a local law that stopped it from billing residents for common-area utilities. Rent concessions also remained a factor.

Essex, UDR and Vivmark raised their full-year same-store revenue forecasts, while Sun Belt-focused Camden and MAA lowered theirs. Camden said September was softer than expected and MAA said new-lease pricing was taking longer to recover.

MAA did report an early sign of improvement heading into the fourth quarter. Its new-resident lease pricing improved from September to October, bucking the usual seasonal pattern.

The positive overall is that tenants are choosing to stay in apartments they already occupy. Now it's about filling up the empty space in certain regions so the discounts in hopes ease.

Source: Globe St.